Joshua J. Peliño October
5, 2023
BA-Philosophy 3 Philosophy
of Language
BERTRAND RUSSELL AND P. STRAWSON THEORY AND
DESCRIPTIONS
In the notion of theory of description, two philosophers
also present their different arguments towards the development of language. Bertrand
Russell offers the idea that definite description in language, it involves a quantifier
and a predicate, and also it involves logical analysis of sentences containing
definite descriptions. In short, Russell viewed description as incomplete symbols
that should be analyzed logically to eliminate any references to nonexistent.
The second idea of description offers to us the idea
that there is distinction between “descriptive” and “singular” reverences. He
emphasizes the importance of ordinary language and his critiques of certain
philosophical traditions, offers to us by the past philosopher. Because of this
different notion, Strawson’s critique the notion of Russells, that it offers
impact on philosophy of language leading to a broader recognition of the
importance of definite description in communication. The idea of two
philosophers shapes the idea of theory of descriptions.
But for some reason I think that the best idea that
offers reality towards the theory of description, is the idea offers to us by
Russell, why? It is because he tries to avoid those non-existential idea that
leads to doubting and it is not existence. We must consider to always put
reality towards every language we use, because if we just put the non-existence
it is more complicated and vaguer for us to understand. We cannot deny the fact
that if we try to evaluate our language it must be leads us to reality.
But
we should also consider some arguments that we cannot fully identify the
reality on every language we have, we can only avoid or disregard those
defected ones but we cannot fully erase it in some cases. We should be mindful in
our language used, it must be logical in order to show reality based on the
given format of description. Lastly, Russell’s theory imposes strict existence
and if it fails the condition, the sentences will leads to absurdity. Absurdity,
I mean that sentence will no longer meaningful because they use defected ones
in the sentences they have.
Comments
Post a Comment